The Cave (2019) Poster

(I) (2019)

User Reviews

Review this title
16 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A first-hand observational film
Lepidopterous_11 November 2019
The Cave is not a didactic or information-driven documentary. It's an actively observational grounding of the audience into a truth you have to see to believe-a spiritual appeal to the senses. For every bomb we see almost hit us, we are spared a screen full of text. For every infant hand we see reaching up for the doctor's stethoscope amidst the chaos following a blast, we are spared a formal, scripted interview sit-down or sound bite. When we see a gassed group of children brought to The Cave to die and wrapped in tablecloths because there are no replacements available for their chemically-stained clothes, we are diverted away from more standard informative fare that attempts to describe the indescribable.

This is not about the state of the Syrian war. This IS the Syrian war, enclosed from both ends, with the relentless reverberations of warplanes flying above ground and the normalization of a day-to-day constant of fear.

Most impactful was the perspective of the pediatrician (the subject of the film). Through clinical training, physicians grow a callus for their patients. Intentionally so, to remain calm, collected, rational. But also unintentionally, to subconsciously remove themselves from the trauma children experience in front of them on a daily basis. Seeing Dr. Amani crack, it destroyed me. Locking herself in the room and weeping, waiting for the next wave, not knowing what's going to come next. "Come home," her father insists on voicemail. But the clinic depends on her. It would be nothing without her. We're reminded that heroes are human and vulnerable.

I felt physically beaten down leaving the theater. I had to play my "It's going to be ok" playlist. I am not sure if it will, but if Amani can help these children find some momentary faith, I think we can all do better.
22 out of 33 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The Cave is brutal and honest, but not as human as its 2019 documentary complement, For Sama
andrewroy-0431631 January 2020
Warning: Spoilers
The fact that I wasn't deeply affected by The Cave and won't think about it much again speaks more to the combination of having already watched For Sama and the fatigue of the death race and school than to a poor job by the filmmakers. As I learned in For Sama, it's upsetting to watch people trying to live and be happy in Syria as the regime attacks innocent people. Amani is amazing, and if one thing works really well in the film, it's the difference one woman made during crisis in Syria. My biggest problem with the film was that it didn't feel human - we don't get to know any of the victims or really even much about the workers, and instead feels more like scene after scene of pain and desperation. Not a bad movie, but I'd recommend watching For Sama and skipping The Cave personally.
10 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Very hard to watch but it's a must-see!
MehdiTaba29 February 2020
It's a great documentary with so many human messages from the start.

Its production values are very good and it's a well-made one.

Sacrificing, danger, fear, war, politics, life and death are among the few themes that you can look through this documentary with the film-maker.

There was another reason that makes watching this documentary hard for me, besides its disturbing imagery which was the fact that my corrupt government is behind all of these and is supporting Bashar al-Assad and its allies to crush Syrian people like this... It's very hard for me to even think about this!

We have so many problems in Iran with our government and they're doing these horrible activities abroad also.

Hope all we can live in a world without these dictators and these totalitarian governments someday...
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Unmissable
margaridaxavier8 December 2019
A raw, brutal testimony of those that were left behind. The cinematography is outstanding. The sound is chilling. A portrait of humankind at both its worst and best. Certainly one of the hardest things I've ever watched, yet doing so might be our only chance to show respect for the heroic healthcare professionals and civilians depicted. It shook me to my core.
31 out of 40 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A sobering essential Doc with a true heroine at its center
gortx27 January 2020
Feras Feyyad's sobering Documentary THE CAVE begins with one of the most striking opening shots of any recent film. A city sits quietly for several moments. And, then a missile comes flying seemingly out of nowhere and explodes. And, then another. And, then another. But, this isn't some Michael Bay Armageddon fantasy - it's a war torn city. And, the 'war' isn't being waged by some invading enemy -- but, by the nation's own leader.

The city is in a province of Syria that was attacked by it's evil tyrant Bashar al-Assad (abetted by Putin's Russia). But, THE CAVE isn't a political film. Instead, its focus isn't on the war on the ground, but by a tunnel burrowed beneath the city of Ghouta. Within those tunnels sits a hospital run by a hundred or so volunteers who chose to stay and help the victims of the constant bombardment rather than flee (or, at the very least, remain with their friends and families). The head of the hospital is Dr. Amani Ballour and unmarried 30ish woman. Beyond the enormous task of running a subterranean medical facility during a time of war, Amani has to assert herself in a patriarchal society which takes a dim view of 'working women' --- even her own family voices displeasure.

Feyyad and his team do laudable work under the circumstances. Feyyad balances the hospital and war horrors with the personal lives of Amani and her personnel. He doesn't dwell on the graphic details, but, doesn't shy away either (fair warning). At any moment a bomb can strike in the city and the entire facility becomes a full on E.R. (the tunnel also functions as a de facto bomb shelter for many). But, during the quieter moments, we see the doctors and laymen go about the mundane details like feeding the crew and trying to get the internet to function so as to keep open channels to the world above. The only real demerit is for Matthew Herbert's overly dramatic musical score. The material not only doesn't lend itself to such an approach, but, with all the sounds of battle and hospital work all around it isn't required.

THE CAVE certainly isn't easy viewing, but, it's an essential piece of filmmaking with a subject in Amani that is worth all the attention coming to her. A heroine.
19 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A masterclass in both documentary filmmaking and in humanity.
javierquesada22 November 2019
While the hospital personnel at The Cave learn to differentiate by sound the different types of warplanes flying overhead and their country of origin for survival, it was the heart-wrenching sound of another stretcher rolling into the hospital while making the floor and walls shake with the weight of a human being fighting for his life that I dreaded the most during my time watching the documentary. As a viewer I was struggling between wondering how much more of the reality presented to me I could take and wanting to reach through the screen and help them. That palpable was their urgency. It is the unfiltered questions coming out of Dr. Amani's own soul during her moments of most abatement and stress like "Is God really watching?" that fall like a bomb and shake the foundations of her own reality and the morals and practices of the culture around her. The Cave is a masterclass in both documentary filmmaking and in humanity.
19 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
More than a great film, an extraordinary experience!
swax-118 November 2019
I urge you to see this great, great film. Despite the harrowing danger, the devastating destruction, this is one of the most uplifting films I've seen in years.
14 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Masterpiece of a hidden reality
Kiacos23 February 2020
Should be rated 12+ This is a paradigm of what war can do. What courage and persistence can achieve. Well brought out to us the ignorant mass.....Well directed and edited!
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The best and most important movie of 2019
wickedmikehampton31 January 2020
More frightening than any Hollywood horror. i was disturbed. I cried. More importantly, I was educated, and applauded. In our hopelessly shallow world with little hope, I clung to the fact that kind and brave people still exist. And kudos (the sincerest) to the survivors of war. 'The Cave' is a motivator for us to be better.

I'd long debated with myself which of the fictions '1917', 'Marriage Story' and 'An Elephant Sitting Still' was the movie of the year but this brutal reality of doctors and their helpers working and living in a labyrinth of caves beneath a war-destroyed city is the clear winner. And that a place it above other shining documentaries such as 'Edge of Democracy' and 'For Sama' strongly expresses how impressed and moved I am.

Director Feras Fayyad, I wish I could shake your hand. Dr. Amani Ballour and everyone like her, I want to hug you in thanks. I'm glad some of you got out. It hurts to think of those doctors and staff arrested after the movie, and the unnamed doctor who died in prison.
8 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of the most powerful documentaries ever!!
pereirol19 May 2020
Thank you, National Geographic for making this masterpiece. Everybody should see the suggles of this hospital and community. This is also a very powerful anti-war and anti-chemical weapon documentary. The hospital team deserve awards for their bravery. The filming makes you feel like you are in the room with them and the shots over Syria as the bombs fall are Devastating. This movie makes you also hate Assad and Russia and feel love for the people of Syria and the doctors and nurses of the cave. Every politician who is deciding their country's path in Syria should see this.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Light in the tunnel: the lowest and highest of humanity
Roma733 March 2020
What a beautiful soul, Amani. Her calm ways, altruism and empathy, her courage and humanity, so pure and incredibly powerful. She radiates that spiritual depth which I suppose was once the starting point of all huge religions before they became corrupted along the way. To me, this is what God is about: people like Amani and her wonderful team, dr. Salim and the rest. If we are to survive as a species, we'll be needing people like them. They are literally the light in the tunnel.

And to the makers of the documentary: incredible job. A palpable claustrophobia like you feel when watching Das Boot, only here it's the real thing.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Heartfelt
alanpuzey2 March 2020
Like a book I couldn't put down. Watched it through to the end and was exhausted, exhilarated and left with a feeling that how on earth has humanity come to this.

I feel powerless. Nothing I can give or do will change this. I look at the world leaders and despair.

Film wise, what a wonderful job the crew did in producing such an outstanding film. I thought virtually everything about it was just right. The characters, the camera work, the sound and editing were mostly spot on.

Thank you.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Remarkable
mjharrison24727 February 2020
This poignant, important documentary is one of the most important pieces of filmmaking of our time. Everybody should be made to watch this as it depicts the atrocities that man is capable of. Set in a Syrian hospital during the ongoing humanitarian crisis of the Bashar regime, Dr. Amani and her team battle relentlessly in their bid to help the war injured. Under immense pressure and with little medical necessities, this team are true heroes. This documentary will have you crying, laughing and smiling throughout this true rollercoaster of emotions. The work of these people are admirable to remain in hell and continue to help, whilst others flee. Dr Amani faces not only the struggles of war and separation from family but also societies norms in a antiquated male heirachy where women are seen as inferior.
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Cave (2019) - 7.4
Bonnell77 February 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Act 1 - 7.1

Act 2 - 7.3

Act 3 - 7.8

Film is about Amani and her team fighting for those who are injured and saving thousands of lives in the cave

Film touches on the sexism of this region and how religion helps suppress the women here

About fighting for something you believe in

Can't help but compare it to For Sama which was a more intimate look at a similar situation

Being filmed by a documentary crew does make the film feel more artificial

Great insight into those fighting for their lives in a war torn country

Strong and impactful film with strong imagery that is worth a watch to learn more about the situation in Syria







Opens with powerful shot of bombs being dropped on Syria

About the people trapped in Ghouta, Syria were a war is being waged on the people

Dr Amani and her team have stayed behind in Syria to help save the wounded in an underground tunnel system and hospital called The Cave

The tunnel system is massively impressive

For Sama and this film both about the Syrian crisis and atrocities

Terrible and heart breaking imagery just like For Sama of people injured and dying from the bombings on their own people for revolting against the regime

Somehow Amani is facing sexism for being the hospital manger and helping hundreds of people and she's being mistreated by some because some think a woman's place is at home and shouldn't be working, old stereotypes in this religious and outdated part of the country are ridiculous

She is saving lives but some think a man could somehow be doing better

Doctors using their limited supplies to do their best

Amani became a doctor to combat the awful world around her and help

Feels less natural than For Sama is the filming isn't done by Amani but an actual documentary crew, less intimate

Follows Amani, operating doctors and supporting staff as new patients keep coming in with injuries

Always hear the planes above and dropping bombs all around them

Constantly watching the news to see their world around them being destroyed by the Regime and Russia

A lot of voiceover from Amani

Have to worry about fortifying the hospital

Cave became a bunker for survival form the war above

Really like the scene with Amani and the girl just talking and connecting to her, emotional, personal moment

Amani even makes some house visits for some kids

Amani says their religion is a tool to suppress women, which I completely agree with is this part of the world

Can't make any decisions for themselves as they are the husbands property

Still finds moments to appreciate life but tragedy is always around the corner

Seeing all the kids injured and in pain is terrible and hard to watch

Infuriating thinking this is allowed to be done to innocent people with little resistance and support from the rest of the onlooking world

Amani questions her place seeing starving children while the hospital is always supplied with food and she never goes hungry, they are running out of medicine

Amani turns 30 and works on her birthday and some of the girls throw a small party for her

But again back to reality with bombs going off nearby

Hospital is in danger and must move some people to the tunnels

More bombs leads to more patients which leads to more death and chaos which affects everyone

So much pain and suffering and fear of the unknown

People are dying from chemical attacks too adding more panic, so messed up to witness, very upsetting

Like the messages form Amani's father

Have to evacuate because no longer safe after chemical attacks

Amani questions her future which is uncertain

Amani and team saved thousands while working in the cave, incredible

Dedicated to those that lost their life fighting for what is right







.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Hope Shines In The Darkest Places
CinemaClown17 February 2020
Nominated for Best Documentary Feature at the last Academy Awards, The Cave is another hard-hitting account of the humanitarian crisis created in the wake of Syrian Civil War, and concerns a group of doctors as they try to save civilian lives with limited medical resources in an underground makeshift hospital.

Directed by Feras Fayyad, his documentary offers ample evidence of war crimes committed by Bashar Regime against its own citizens, including use of chemical weapons, but the presentation isn't up to the mark. Several segments look as if they were rehearsed before filming, and are lacking the spontaneity that makes them click.

Amidst the daily airstrikes & bombings, it also sheds light on the systemic sexism as even in an environment where death lurks above, a man feels an obligation to tell a female doctor why she should be at home instead of trying to save human lives. But this element is also later overplayed by the director as if he just wanted to drive a point home.

Like any documentary covering the subject of war, The Cave is graphic, disturbing & uncomfortable. Yet unlike most Syrian documentaries, it has a more polished & refined quality, almost like a feature film shot in an active war zone. It is also way more focused on a single person than the collective effort yet unlike For Sama, it is lacking that raw, personal touch.

Overall, The Cave is as gripping as it is heartbreaking but its impact is rather short lived. There are some tense moments that are expertly documented, including the gas attack that's just soul-shattering, but its narrative lacks a compelling structure and becomes repetitive after a while. Bringing to light the brutal reality of doctors operating in labyrinth of caves beneath a war-torn city, The Cave is worth a shot.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A powerful film
breadandhammers31 May 2021
Warning: Spoilers
The Cave follows the story of Syrian doctor Amani Ballour as she stays behind in the Al-Ghota region on the outskirts of Damascus. The documentary is a harrowing on-the-ground look at the doctors dealing with constant bombings from warplanes. The whirring sound of warplanes is a constant feature. To protect against the bombings, the doctors have built an underground cave tunnel system for the patients.

This is a powerful film that shows the result of a government attacking its own people. Every time the camera cuts to an exterior shot, and I see hollowed out buildings and rubble, I have to remind myself that it's not a post-apocalyptic fictional set, but rather real life. The documentary shows the resilience of the doctors, peppered in with light moments of humanity - them celebrating Amani's birthday, or cooking. It is a powerful film.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed