After getting a high score on an entrance exam, Alan is accepted to a prestigious high school. While Phyllis is excited about the news, Alan and others have reservations about going to a new school.
When Katie's family objects to him taking Katie to a couples only party, Alan comes up with a plan where he asks Benny's dream girl to the party, has Benny escort Katie and then they switch dates at the party.
Following a fight with Alan, Benny temporarily goes missing. When the dust is settled, Alan must come clean to Karen while Katie is forced to come clean with Benny.
Katie's sister announces that she has eloped, gotten pregnant and will be moving to California. Everyone is happy for her except for her father, who refuses to attend the going away party.
After Katie's father refuses to let her continue seeing Alan due to their religious differences, Alan and his family setup a dinner appointment with her family in the hope of breaking the ice.