This is a perfect example of movie critics being out of touch with audiences. Is Boondock Saints a revolutionary film filled with epiphanies? No. Is it a fun (and surprisingly heartwarming at times) watch? YES! The love the two brothers feel for each other and the commitment they feel to doing right by each other and punishing others who commit evil hits home and raises the question: do two wrongs make a right? Does punishing evil justify violence? The movie is over the top, funny, and packed with action that doesn't bore or drag on. Honestly a must-watch!