This story of a young Frenchman, Marius, who makes an anguished decision to pursue his personal passion for sailing the open seas at the expense of foregoing the love of the beautiful Fanny (Leslie Caron) would have played well as a straight drama, but it is undermined by scenes hardly worthy of a situation comedy. This is unfortunate since there are quality actors on board and some truly dramatic scenes.
Consider the game that the older folks play while sitting outside Marius' father's bar. They set out a large rock and cover it with a hat and wait for passersby to kick it. For one thing I don't think it is a normal reaction to want to kick a hat that is sitting alone on a busy sidewalk. Secondly, serious injury could result if someone were so inclined to kick it. The poor priest who took the bait is seen limping off after his experience - I felt sorry for him and irritated with the perpetrators who found this so humorous. It is astonishing how many things are wrong with that scene, but the main problem is that it sets an inappropriate tone for what is to come. This low tone is continued in the scene where the seventy-year-old Maurice Chevallier puts the moves on the young Caron provoking a melodramatic response of jealousy in Marius - that scene indeed could come right out of a situation comedy, as could so many others. In spite of the significant themes that are to come we get the feeling that nothing serious is really going on here.
We very quickly arrive at the crucial scene where Marius decides to sign on to a seagoing scientific ship for a five year tour. This just after he and Fanny have consummated their love on the previous night. This key scene is poorly motivated - we have little appreciation for Marius' passion for the sea and a minimal understanding of the relationship between Marius and Fanny. There might as well just have been a voice-over saying that Marius loved both the sea and Fanny.
There are many plot inconsistencies. In one of the final scenes Marius is called on an emergency mission while at work as a grease monkey. He arrives dressed in a suit.
Meaningful themes are dealt with such as the relationships between parents and children, conflicting desires, difficult decisions, pragmatism versus passion, friendship, failure to communicate, and sacrifice. Great material whose potential is only occasionally realized.
The filming is quite beautiful. There is one scene that lingers in the mind that has the young lovers embracing in an alleyway lighted by an amber street-lamp. The Marseille setting is used to great effect and probably has accounted for some increased tourism.
Leslie Caron alone makes this worth the time and it *is* fun to see Charles Boyer and Maurice Chevalier play off each other. Horst Bucholz was a handsome young man - quite a shock to see him thirty-six years later in "Life is Beautiful." No one escapes the effects of aging.
Consider the game that the older folks play while sitting outside Marius' father's bar. They set out a large rock and cover it with a hat and wait for passersby to kick it. For one thing I don't think it is a normal reaction to want to kick a hat that is sitting alone on a busy sidewalk. Secondly, serious injury could result if someone were so inclined to kick it. The poor priest who took the bait is seen limping off after his experience - I felt sorry for him and irritated with the perpetrators who found this so humorous. It is astonishing how many things are wrong with that scene, but the main problem is that it sets an inappropriate tone for what is to come. This low tone is continued in the scene where the seventy-year-old Maurice Chevallier puts the moves on the young Caron provoking a melodramatic response of jealousy in Marius - that scene indeed could come right out of a situation comedy, as could so many others. In spite of the significant themes that are to come we get the feeling that nothing serious is really going on here.
We very quickly arrive at the crucial scene where Marius decides to sign on to a seagoing scientific ship for a five year tour. This just after he and Fanny have consummated their love on the previous night. This key scene is poorly motivated - we have little appreciation for Marius' passion for the sea and a minimal understanding of the relationship between Marius and Fanny. There might as well just have been a voice-over saying that Marius loved both the sea and Fanny.
There are many plot inconsistencies. In one of the final scenes Marius is called on an emergency mission while at work as a grease monkey. He arrives dressed in a suit.
Meaningful themes are dealt with such as the relationships between parents and children, conflicting desires, difficult decisions, pragmatism versus passion, friendship, failure to communicate, and sacrifice. Great material whose potential is only occasionally realized.
The filming is quite beautiful. There is one scene that lingers in the mind that has the young lovers embracing in an alleyway lighted by an amber street-lamp. The Marseille setting is used to great effect and probably has accounted for some increased tourism.
Leslie Caron alone makes this worth the time and it *is* fun to see Charles Boyer and Maurice Chevalier play off each other. Horst Bucholz was a handsome young man - quite a shock to see him thirty-six years later in "Life is Beautiful." No one escapes the effects of aging.