Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Young Adam (2003)
5/10
A film that disappointed me with a tenuous story line.
10 May 2005
The film had a story line which consisted of one sexual intercourse to another. The director seemed to have a particular liking for the sexual scenes being seen through cracks in the wall. This did not detract from some very fine acting, in particular, Tilda Swinton. Her portrayal of a world weary and caring mother was the highlight of the film. The role played by Ewen McGregor, although reasonably acted ,did not stretch his, already proved, ability. I would suggest that the requirement to look moody and simulate the sex act was not really his forte. The majority of the action takes place on a canal barge and the director managed to convey the claustrophobic atmosphere to perfection. It was not a film to see if you wanted an entertaining evening.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A film that enhances all thats good in British cinema
6 February 2005
The film, directed by Charles Dance, is the epitome of good, low budget, British cinema. Two major actresses, Judy dench and Maggie Smith underplay their parts very well. Maggie Smith has that special gift of "scene stealing". The locations were superb and true to life as I remember that era well. The casting director gathered a supporting cast who added to the enjoyment of the film. My only complaint was that the editing for the first 30mins of the film lacked sympathy with the plot and, at times, very abrupt. The question of how the boy got into the water is never explained but it didn't matter because the script was more of a story without a beginning and without end. A great film, I loved it!
83 out of 99 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed