Jonathan has shown us that in order to make a holocaust movie you don't have to kill thousands of people on screen or burn them in those concentration camps or drop dead due to hunger and cold, but just instil fear and hatred in the viewers by simply showing us the mundane activities of a nazi commandant family by creating a combination of sounds from an immersive environment in the background. You're constantly reminded of what's going over the fence but because of the disconnect in the audio and the video, it creates an unsettling feeling in the viewer's mind which is truly horrific.
Without a doubt this is the work of a genius because right from the start the director made sure to create an unsettling feeling in the audiences minds, he created such a disturbing atmosphere with just his opening credits where it took a minute for the title to disappear and immediately a 2mins black screen with a bone chilling score and he does the same at around 45min mark for a min or two when the screen fades to red completely. We do not see any characters carrying out violence rather they spend most of their time in the garden growing vegetables, children playing around, celebrating the commandant's birthday and fishing etc., but still the entire Hoss family is pure evil because they choose to simply ignore of what's happening over the wall but worried more about their materialistic life and dreams. Again not everyone is able to ignore the horrors around them because when Hedwig's mother comes to stay with her, initially she's in awe around those highly sophisticated materialistic things but things start to slowly dawn on her, when she wakes up in the middle of the night not able to withstand the stench of the death and the sight of the flaming gas, she leaves in the middle of the night leaving a note for her daughter. And the director also made sure to visually display the fear on screen by having the workers walk around the Hoss residency, garden, cleaning the blood off of the boots etc., trying to complete their works on time and be perfect at the same time.
The scenes which captivated me most are the ones that were shot with military grade thermal camera. We see a girl leaving apples for the prisoners in the nights and during its first sequence I was unable to comprehend the meaning of it when Rudolf Hoss asks his daughter, who's sitting by the window as to what she's doing and I thought that the small girl was just looking out the window imagining herself helping the people fighting the war by leaving them apples. But during the later sequences I understood that, she's an altogether a different kid, whom the director just decided to show her acts of kindness during the war by simply not making the overall movie look too dark.
And the most ambiguous part of the movie is the final sequence where Rudolf Hoss starts to retch when he's walking down the stairs and out of the blue he stops and stares into the darkness across the corridor and the director suddenly fast forwards the time to the current day Auschwitz where we see some of the museum workers taking care of all those dead people relics and again takes us back to Rudolf where he again starts to retch after getting down another flight of stairs. I have read different versions of this like "Hoss saw the future of his atrocities", "Maybe a consequence of the pollutants at the camp", "That his body rejects his idea of killing all those 700k Hungarians but his mind doesn't and that's the reason for his retching", "Director was trying to show us that Hoss and his ideas doesn't matter and they're considered as inhuman and he's considered as evil who was tried for mass murder but the deaths of all those people and their sufferings will be remembered forever" etc.
This is a brilliant movie with an outstanding and terrifying score by Mica Levi which gets made once in a decade or so but at the same time you'll think twice to rewatch it because you're afraid of it. If you haven't seen this already I highly recommend you to watch this especially for the way how asynchronous the audio and video are.
Without a doubt this is the work of a genius because right from the start the director made sure to create an unsettling feeling in the audiences minds, he created such a disturbing atmosphere with just his opening credits where it took a minute for the title to disappear and immediately a 2mins black screen with a bone chilling score and he does the same at around 45min mark for a min or two when the screen fades to red completely. We do not see any characters carrying out violence rather they spend most of their time in the garden growing vegetables, children playing around, celebrating the commandant's birthday and fishing etc., but still the entire Hoss family is pure evil because they choose to simply ignore of what's happening over the wall but worried more about their materialistic life and dreams. Again not everyone is able to ignore the horrors around them because when Hedwig's mother comes to stay with her, initially she's in awe around those highly sophisticated materialistic things but things start to slowly dawn on her, when she wakes up in the middle of the night not able to withstand the stench of the death and the sight of the flaming gas, she leaves in the middle of the night leaving a note for her daughter. And the director also made sure to visually display the fear on screen by having the workers walk around the Hoss residency, garden, cleaning the blood off of the boots etc., trying to complete their works on time and be perfect at the same time.
The scenes which captivated me most are the ones that were shot with military grade thermal camera. We see a girl leaving apples for the prisoners in the nights and during its first sequence I was unable to comprehend the meaning of it when Rudolf Hoss asks his daughter, who's sitting by the window as to what she's doing and I thought that the small girl was just looking out the window imagining herself helping the people fighting the war by leaving them apples. But during the later sequences I understood that, she's an altogether a different kid, whom the director just decided to show her acts of kindness during the war by simply not making the overall movie look too dark.
And the most ambiguous part of the movie is the final sequence where Rudolf Hoss starts to retch when he's walking down the stairs and out of the blue he stops and stares into the darkness across the corridor and the director suddenly fast forwards the time to the current day Auschwitz where we see some of the museum workers taking care of all those dead people relics and again takes us back to Rudolf where he again starts to retch after getting down another flight of stairs. I have read different versions of this like "Hoss saw the future of his atrocities", "Maybe a consequence of the pollutants at the camp", "That his body rejects his idea of killing all those 700k Hungarians but his mind doesn't and that's the reason for his retching", "Director was trying to show us that Hoss and his ideas doesn't matter and they're considered as inhuman and he's considered as evil who was tried for mass murder but the deaths of all those people and their sufferings will be remembered forever" etc.
This is a brilliant movie with an outstanding and terrifying score by Mica Levi which gets made once in a decade or so but at the same time you'll think twice to rewatch it because you're afraid of it. If you haven't seen this already I highly recommend you to watch this especially for the way how asynchronous the audio and video are.
Tell Your Friends