Kirsten Dunst, Wagner Moura and Stephen McKinley Henderson are world weary journalists and photo journalists in the near future, en route to Washington DC amidst an American Civil War. Their goal, interview the President before D. C. falls under siege. Along the way they pick up a wet behind the ears aspiring photojournalist, played by Cailee Spaeny. The closer they get to D. C. the harder their travails as they work through city street battles, snipers, self appointed civilian militias and finally a war zone while testing their work-craft, humanity and even their sanity.
The film is magnificent storytelling. There is no single weak scene, performance or spoken word in the entirety of the movie and that's a feat unto itself in any film. The battle sequences are as tense and visceral as any filmed, rivaling Full Metal Jacket and Saving Private Ryan. The cinematography is masterful and I would point to one scene in particular where the group is camping out at some sort of factory and the shot was framed so expertly that the entire theater became the stage. I was in awe and will be surprised if any film this year can do better.
My only complaint has nothing to do with the film itself but instead with its place in our current political discourse. Garland steers clear of specifically stating who or what is responsible for the state of affairs in the U. S. he imagines. California and Texas have seceded and joined sides against the U. S., (with Florida on the fence about doing the same) a jokingly unbelievable alliance in the current real world, but the third term President (the always excellent Nick Offerman) is clearly a Trump substitute.
What was Garland making? A satire? A morality tale? It doesn't seem to be either of those nor is it total fiction. He's either optimistic or naive to portray California and Florida as allies even against his fictional President. It is much closer to being an exploitation film, preying on the political discourse to get bodies in the seats while trying at the same time to not offend any particular audience's political sensibilities. It would have been far braver to pick a clear side which would have elevated this film and possibly made it historically relevant. I'm only guessing at his intentions and results but it's a damn fine film.
I'm giving 9 stars. -.1 for pretending to be relevant.
A must see.
The film is magnificent storytelling. There is no single weak scene, performance or spoken word in the entirety of the movie and that's a feat unto itself in any film. The battle sequences are as tense and visceral as any filmed, rivaling Full Metal Jacket and Saving Private Ryan. The cinematography is masterful and I would point to one scene in particular where the group is camping out at some sort of factory and the shot was framed so expertly that the entire theater became the stage. I was in awe and will be surprised if any film this year can do better.
My only complaint has nothing to do with the film itself but instead with its place in our current political discourse. Garland steers clear of specifically stating who or what is responsible for the state of affairs in the U. S. he imagines. California and Texas have seceded and joined sides against the U. S., (with Florida on the fence about doing the same) a jokingly unbelievable alliance in the current real world, but the third term President (the always excellent Nick Offerman) is clearly a Trump substitute.
What was Garland making? A satire? A morality tale? It doesn't seem to be either of those nor is it total fiction. He's either optimistic or naive to portray California and Florida as allies even against his fictional President. It is much closer to being an exploitation film, preying on the political discourse to get bodies in the seats while trying at the same time to not offend any particular audience's political sensibilities. It would have been far braver to pick a clear side which would have elevated this film and possibly made it historically relevant. I'm only guessing at his intentions and results but it's a damn fine film.
I'm giving 9 stars. -.1 for pretending to be relevant.
A must see.
Tell Your Friends