As the title says this film is very uneven, with some segments being a boring mess and some being legitimately frightening and fun to watch.
If I were to rate each short:
Tape 56/Frame Narrative - Didn't really care about anything that was happening. I just wanted them to move onto the next short. 4/10
Amateur Night - In my opinion, the best of the bunch. It's a really entertaining watch and a very strong first segment to follow the weak wrap-around story at the beginning. 8.5/10
Second Honeymoon - Quite silly and a bit confusing. Not very interesting. Ti West has done much better work than this before. 4/10
Tuesday, The 17th - The characters are quite annoying and so is some of the sound design, but overall this is an entertaining segment. 6/10
The Sick Thing That Happened to Emily When She Was Younger - A very unique segment as its done through video chat. Kind of a cool idea that doesn't have a great payoff. 5.5/10
10/31/98 - Although I had said "Amateur Night" is the best segment, this one is by far the most effective as a horror film. This was the only segment that legitimately freaked me out and I actually went back and watched it again. 8.5/10
If I were to rate each short:
Tape 56/Frame Narrative - Didn't really care about anything that was happening. I just wanted them to move onto the next short. 4/10
Amateur Night - In my opinion, the best of the bunch. It's a really entertaining watch and a very strong first segment to follow the weak wrap-around story at the beginning. 8.5/10
Second Honeymoon - Quite silly and a bit confusing. Not very interesting. Ti West has done much better work than this before. 4/10
Tuesday, The 17th - The characters are quite annoying and so is some of the sound design, but overall this is an entertaining segment. 6/10
The Sick Thing That Happened to Emily When She Was Younger - A very unique segment as its done through video chat. Kind of a cool idea that doesn't have a great payoff. 5.5/10
10/31/98 - Although I had said "Amateur Night" is the best segment, this one is by far the most effective as a horror film. This was the only segment that legitimately freaked me out and I actually went back and watched it again. 8.5/10
Tell Your Friends