I actually saw YOU'RE NEXT (2011) back when it first hit theaters over a decade ago and at the time had mixed feelings and not sure what to make of it other than it seemed like a passable horror film. But having re-visited it a couple of times over the years including a relatively recent horror movie watching marathon, it's actually a pretty weak entry into the genre that doesn't really hold up. I'm pretty sure that this film was actually billed as a "comedy-horror" when it first came out, the overall vibe of the movie is serious even although it does have several unintentionally funny moments. One thing I actually DO remember disliking about this movie was the insane plot armor of it's main character and "final girl" Erin (played by Sharni Vinson). Erin appears to be a popular final girl among the horror community, the typical badass female character that is better than every other character for simply surviving the night. Full disclosure, my all time favorite final girl is Sarah Connor from The Terminator and the REASON that Sarah was a badass had nothing to do being able to protect herself or because she was good with weapons and talked in a husky gravelly voice (all of which she did in the heavily overrated T2). Nope, Sarah was badass because of exceptional writing and acting for a character that felt completely lived in and relatable and who had a real arc throughout the film. T1 Sarah is pretty much the gold standard by which I judge final girls in horror. And Erin is most definitely no T1 Sarah! LOL Erin is conveniently a survivalist and has all these amazing skills with every kind of weapon. Herein lies my first problem with the film. I don't care how much of a survivalist someone is, there is absolutely nothing that could have prepared Erin for the events of this film.
The plot of this movie involves recent college graduate Erin on a holiday retreat with her boyfriend Crispian's (played by AJ Bowen) family. The family dinner holiday is hosted by the family matriarch Aubrey (played by horror movie icon and former soap opera actress Barbara Crampton) and patriarch Paul (played by Rob Moran). Crispian (unusual name that I've never heard before or after this film) was one of Erin's college professors that she fell in love with and when Crispian's jokey older brother Drake (played by Joe Swanberg) mumbled at the dinner table about it being inappropriate, I kind of agreed with him. In addition to Drake and Crispian, rounding out the sibling quartet are Aimee (played Amy Siemetz, an actual good actress that I've seen in other movies) and Felix (played by Nicholas Tucci). A couple other notable characters are Felix's girlfriend Zee (played by Wendy Glenn) and Aimee's boyfriend Tariq (played by none other than director Ti West who directed an actual GOOD horror film House of the Devil from 2009). The family and their significant others get attacked by a trio of masked psychos on the first night, all armed with bows and arrows for some reason. Returning to my aforementioned first problem with the movie of Erin being fully prepared for the attack, so we find out near the end of the film that Crispian was in on it all along and he wanted Erin to survive so they could be rich off his inheritance, then why would he even invite her there to put her in imminent danger in the first place? That makes no sense. Also, if he knew that she had survival skills and was 100% sure she would survive, why would the younger brother even allow the possibility of Erin screwing up their plans? Crispian, Felix, and Zee were all in on the plan so why let a completely oblivious outsider and wildcard like Erin even be part of the action? Also, the masked attackers were probably told to leave Erin alone, but there's no way that would adhere to that given she was hellbent on killing them to defend herself. She should never have even been at the retreat in the first place, yet she's the actual main character that survives the whole night. It reeks of the writers needing an excuse to have an unbeatable main character with absurd plot armor.
The second problem is that Erin's toughness felt completely unbelievable. She didn't come across as someone who could handle herself and also she had no idea what she was up against. It's like the character knew what both the audience and the actress knew because Erin was completely prepared for everything. She's just another shallow, undefined, magical girlboss character that moviegoers fawn over because she's good with weapons, the equivalent of a lead in a mindless 80s action movie. The final problem with the movie are the odd comedy moments. Like I said, the movie does actually have humor, but it feels forced and almost unintentional, like when the oldest brother was shocked the youngest was in on the plan and the younger brother yells for him to just die and when the overly quirky sister yells at the family that she can run for help. The movie had a lot of silly moments that undercut it's dramatic horror vibe. The movie ends with yet another oddly unintentional comical moment when the ONE cop that arrives gets blasted by one of Erin's traps and then roll credits. Everything about this horror film felt unnecessary, from the weird awkward comedy to the forgettable 1-dimensional characters and finally to the ridiculously overpowered main character with all the plot armor in the world.
The plot of this movie involves recent college graduate Erin on a holiday retreat with her boyfriend Crispian's (played by AJ Bowen) family. The family dinner holiday is hosted by the family matriarch Aubrey (played by horror movie icon and former soap opera actress Barbara Crampton) and patriarch Paul (played by Rob Moran). Crispian (unusual name that I've never heard before or after this film) was one of Erin's college professors that she fell in love with and when Crispian's jokey older brother Drake (played by Joe Swanberg) mumbled at the dinner table about it being inappropriate, I kind of agreed with him. In addition to Drake and Crispian, rounding out the sibling quartet are Aimee (played Amy Siemetz, an actual good actress that I've seen in other movies) and Felix (played by Nicholas Tucci). A couple other notable characters are Felix's girlfriend Zee (played by Wendy Glenn) and Aimee's boyfriend Tariq (played by none other than director Ti West who directed an actual GOOD horror film House of the Devil from 2009). The family and their significant others get attacked by a trio of masked psychos on the first night, all armed with bows and arrows for some reason. Returning to my aforementioned first problem with the movie of Erin being fully prepared for the attack, so we find out near the end of the film that Crispian was in on it all along and he wanted Erin to survive so they could be rich off his inheritance, then why would he even invite her there to put her in imminent danger in the first place? That makes no sense. Also, if he knew that she had survival skills and was 100% sure she would survive, why would the younger brother even allow the possibility of Erin screwing up their plans? Crispian, Felix, and Zee were all in on the plan so why let a completely oblivious outsider and wildcard like Erin even be part of the action? Also, the masked attackers were probably told to leave Erin alone, but there's no way that would adhere to that given she was hellbent on killing them to defend herself. She should never have even been at the retreat in the first place, yet she's the actual main character that survives the whole night. It reeks of the writers needing an excuse to have an unbeatable main character with absurd plot armor.
The second problem is that Erin's toughness felt completely unbelievable. She didn't come across as someone who could handle herself and also she had no idea what she was up against. It's like the character knew what both the audience and the actress knew because Erin was completely prepared for everything. She's just another shallow, undefined, magical girlboss character that moviegoers fawn over because she's good with weapons, the equivalent of a lead in a mindless 80s action movie. The final problem with the movie are the odd comedy moments. Like I said, the movie does actually have humor, but it feels forced and almost unintentional, like when the oldest brother was shocked the youngest was in on the plan and the younger brother yells for him to just die and when the overly quirky sister yells at the family that she can run for help. The movie had a lot of silly moments that undercut it's dramatic horror vibe. The movie ends with yet another oddly unintentional comical moment when the ONE cop that arrives gets blasted by one of Erin's traps and then roll credits. Everything about this horror film felt unnecessary, from the weird awkward comedy to the forgettable 1-dimensional characters and finally to the ridiculously overpowered main character with all the plot armor in the world.
Tell Your Friends