Back in the day I watched Voyager until Kes was removed, that iffed me so much that I stopped watching. Today many decades later and with a very different outlook thanks to a lot of media consumption, that might not have been the best decision. Then again, maybe it wasn't so bad.
I think it's impossible not to compare Voyager to TNG, and having watched them through back-to-back, that is what I will do. When seeing TNG, every episode is like being a part of a family, with well-crafted and likeable characters that drive the episodes forward. It is the epitome of Roddenberry's vision, a future where not only the technology has progressed leaps and bounds, but where society and people have as well. They have done away with capitalism, and people join Star Fleet to explore the galaxy, not to be slaves to an outdated predatory monetary system. Along with this comes a progression of mankind as well, there is no rat race. People aboard the Federation star ships have no reason to squabble and engage in conflicts amongst themselves. The drama is created in meeting the alien races and their societies. This is where Voyager doesn't quite reach the heights of TNG.
From the first episode to the last, most of the main characters in Voyager are very one-dimensional and never spark much interest. I would say all except for the Doctor, Seven of Nine and Janeway. To add to this, there is a snarkiness and sarcasm in the exchanges that I can never get over. Tom Paris is the worst offender for this. I think they are basically bullying Tuvok throughout the series. Instead of getting rid of Kes, they should've spaced Neelix and Paris. I think this is one of the areas where Voyager shows its age, people acted like this in the 90's and somehow it was OK.
Seasons one to three are very rough, a low point is the pilot where they have been transported to a planet 75000 light years away, and travel on an escalator... The arrival of Seven of Nine in season four marks the point where the show becomes good. Like others have pointed out Voyager would've worked much better as a more focused narrative on trying to get home, as opposed to the very unfocused result we got, where there are countless shore leaves, not to mention the holodeck episodes which are the worst.
I liked having seen the entire series now, but I can't see myself rewatching it, as opposed to TNG which I look forward to seeing again at some point. There are individual episodes of Voyager that are great, but as a whole the lack of good characters becomes an innate problem that prevents it from reaching its true potential.
I think it's impossible not to compare Voyager to TNG, and having watched them through back-to-back, that is what I will do. When seeing TNG, every episode is like being a part of a family, with well-crafted and likeable characters that drive the episodes forward. It is the epitome of Roddenberry's vision, a future where not only the technology has progressed leaps and bounds, but where society and people have as well. They have done away with capitalism, and people join Star Fleet to explore the galaxy, not to be slaves to an outdated predatory monetary system. Along with this comes a progression of mankind as well, there is no rat race. People aboard the Federation star ships have no reason to squabble and engage in conflicts amongst themselves. The drama is created in meeting the alien races and their societies. This is where Voyager doesn't quite reach the heights of TNG.
From the first episode to the last, most of the main characters in Voyager are very one-dimensional and never spark much interest. I would say all except for the Doctor, Seven of Nine and Janeway. To add to this, there is a snarkiness and sarcasm in the exchanges that I can never get over. Tom Paris is the worst offender for this. I think they are basically bullying Tuvok throughout the series. Instead of getting rid of Kes, they should've spaced Neelix and Paris. I think this is one of the areas where Voyager shows its age, people acted like this in the 90's and somehow it was OK.
Seasons one to three are very rough, a low point is the pilot where they have been transported to a planet 75000 light years away, and travel on an escalator... The arrival of Seven of Nine in season four marks the point where the show becomes good. Like others have pointed out Voyager would've worked much better as a more focused narrative on trying to get home, as opposed to the very unfocused result we got, where there are countless shore leaves, not to mention the holodeck episodes which are the worst.
I liked having seen the entire series now, but I can't see myself rewatching it, as opposed to TNG which I look forward to seeing again at some point. There are individual episodes of Voyager that are great, but as a whole the lack of good characters becomes an innate problem that prevents it from reaching its true potential.
Tell Your Friends