- OvertureMusic by Jule Styne and Moose CharlapPerformed by the orchestra
- Tender ShepherdMusic by Moose CharlapLyrics by Carolyn Leigh
- I Gotta Crow!Music by Moose CharlapLyrics by Carolyn LeighPerformed by Allison Williams
- Never Never LandMusic by Jule StyneLyrics by Betty Comden and Adolph GreenPerformed by Allison Williams
- I'm FlyingMusic by Moose CharlapLyrics by Carolyn Leigh
- Pirate MarchMusic by Moose CharlapLyrics by Carolyn Leigh and Amanda GreenPerformed by Christian Borle and the pirates
- Vengeance(Adaptation of "Ambition" from the musical "Do-Re-Mi")Music by Jule StyneOriginal lyrics by Betty Comden and Adolph GreenNew lyrics by Amanda GreenPerformed by Christopher Walken, Christian Borle, and the pirates
- Pirate March(reprise)Music by Moose CharlapLyrics by Carolyn Leigh and Amanda GreenPerformed by Christian Borle and the pirates
- Hook's TangoMusic by Moose CharlapLyrics by Carolyn LeighPerformed by Christopher Walken, Christian Borle, and the pirates
- WendyMusic by Jule StyneLyrics by Betty Comden and Adolph GreenPerformed by Allison Williams and the Lost Boys
- Hook's TarantellaMusic by Moose CharlapLyrics by Carolyn LeighPerformed by Christopher Walken, Christian Borle, and the pirates
- I Won't Grow Up!Music by Moose CharlapLyrics by Carolyn Leigh
- Only Pretend(Adaptation of "I Know About Love" from the musical "Do Re Mi")Music by Jule StyneOriginal lyrics by Betty Comden and Adolph GreenNew lyrics by Amanda GreenPerformed by Taylor Louderman
- A Wonderful World Without Peter(Adaptation of "Something's Always Happening on the River" from the musical "Say, Darling")Music by Jule StyneOriginal lyrics by Betty Comden and Adolph GreenNew lyrics by Amanda GreenPerformed by Allison Williams and Christopher Walken
- True Blood Brothers(adaptation of "Ugg-a-Wugg")Music by Jule StyneOriginal lyrics by Betty Comden and Adolph GreenNew lyrics by Amanda GreenPerformed by Allison Williams, Alanna Saunders, the Lost Boys, and the Indians
- Distant MelodyMusic by Jule StyneLyrics by Betty Comden and Adolph GreenPerformed by Taylor Louderman and Kelli O'Hara
- When I Went HomeMusic by Moose CharlapLyrics by Carolyn LeighPerformed by Allison Williams
- I'm Flying (Reprise)Music by Moose CharlapLyrics by Amanda GreenPerformed by Allison Williams
- Hook's WaltzMusic by Jule StyneLyrics by Betty Comden and Adolph GreenPerformed by Christopher Walken, Christian Borle, and the pirates
- I Gotta Crow (Reprise)Music by Moose CharlapLyrics by Carolyn LeighPerformed by Allison Williams and the cast
- Only Pretend/Tender Shepherd (Reprise)Music by Jule Styne and Moose CharlapNew lyrics by Amanda Green
- I Won't Grow Up (Reprise)Music by Moose CharlapLyrics by Carolyn LeighPerformed by Kelli O'Hara, Taylor Louderman, Jake Lucas, John Allyn, Christian Borle, and the Lost Boys
- Finale UltimoMusic by Jule StyneLyrics by Betty Comden and Adolph GreenPerformed by Allison Williams
Contribute to this page
Suggest an edit or add missing content