Eleniak became pregnant in 2005, but six and a half weeks into her term, the pregnancy was discovered to be ectopic, which required emergency surgery days later. It ended in miscarriage.
In a relationship with Roch Daigle since 2001. They have a daughter together, Indyanna Daigle (b. January 2006).
Appeared on the Playboy Magazine issue July 1989, which was used in the film Home Alone (1990).